Stems vs. a stereo mix: when each one actually makes sense to send
23/05/2026
One of the most common questions I get before a project starts is some version of: should I send stems or a stereo mix? It is a reasonable question and the answer is not always obvious, especially if you are new to working with an audio engineer.
The short answer is: it depends on what needs to be done. The longer answer is worth understanding, because sending the wrong thing can either limit what is possible or create unnecessary work for both sides.
What a stereo mix is
A stereo mix is a single file — two channels, left and right — that contains everything in your recording bounced together. All the instruments, all the vocals, all the processing you have applied, collapsed into one piece of audio.
This is what you send for mastering. Mastering works on the finished mix as a whole: it shapes the tonal balance, manages the dynamic range, and prepares the track for its intended format and platform. It does not — and cannot — make changes to individual instruments or elements within the mix, because they are all already baked into the same file.
If you send a stereo mix and ask for a specific instrument to be louder or the reverb on the vocals to be reduced, that is not something mastering can address. The stereo mix is the endpoint of the mixing process, and mastering starts from there.
What stems are
Stems are separate files for different groups of elements within the mix: drums, bass, guitars, keys, lead vocals, backing vocals, and so on. They are exported individually from your DAW so that the person receiving them can control the balance and processing of each group independently.
Stems are used when the project needs editing or mixing work — not just mastering. If a producer or engineer is going to mix your tracks, they need the individual elements to work with. If you are sending a recording for live editing and the drum levels need adjusting relative to the rest of the band, stems make that possible. If the lead vocal needs to come up without affecting the guitars, stems are the only way to do it.
Think of stems as the ingredients. A stereo mix is the finished dish. Handing over a finished dish and asking someone to change the seasoning is not really possible — but handing over the ingredients means anything can be adjusted.
When to send a stereo mix
Send a stereo mix when:
- Your mix is finished and you want it mastered for release
- You are happy with the balance and processing of all elements and only need the overall loudness, tonal balance, and format preparation addressed
- You are releasing to streaming platforms, on CD, or to any format that requires a mastered file
In this situation, export from your DAW with the master bus processing turned off or bypassed (or discuss this with your mastering engineer first — some prefer to receive the mix with certain processing in place). Leave headroom. Aim for peaks around -6 dBFS. Export as WAV or AIFF at 24-bit depth.
When to send stems
Send stems when:
- Your recording needs editing or mixing — not just mastering
- There are balance issues between elements that you want addressed
- You are sending a live recording that needs individual elements separated for editing
- The engineer you are working with has asked for stems specifically
When exporting stems, every stem should start at bar one, beat one — the same point in time — so they line up correctly when imported into another DAW. Export all stems at the same sample rate and bit depth. Label them clearly: drums, bass, guitars, lead vox, and so on. Do not apply heavy compression or limiting to individual stems before exporting — that processing should happen at the mixing stage, not baked into the raw material.
The hybrid situation: multi-track
A step beyond stems is sending the full multi-track — individual tracks for every element rather than grouped stems. Separate microphone channels for the drum kit, DI and mic tracks for bass and guitar, each vocal take on its own track.
This gives the engineer maximum flexibility and is the standard for a full mixing project. If you recorded in a professional studio, you will likely have the session file or multi-track exports available. If you recorded at home in a DAW, exporting all individual tracks from the session is straightforward — it just takes a few extra minutes to do it properly.
Multi-track is overkill for mastering and unnecessary if you are happy with your mix. It is the right choice if you want a professional mix done from scratch.
A practical summary
If your mix is done and you want it mastered: send a stereo mix.
If something in the mix still needs to change: send stems or multi-track and explain what needs addressing.
If you are not sure which category you are in: send a quick message first and describe where you are in the process. A short conversation before files are sent almost always saves time on both sides.
When in doubt, it costs nothing to ask.